Sheet Pan Lemon Balsamic Chicken

When you want a colorful and deeply flavorful dinner with hardly any cleanup, this Sheet Pan Lemon Balsamic Chicken and Potatoes always delivers. Everything caramelizes in the oven and that lemony herb topping is the secret magic. I pull out this sheet pan meal for busy weeknights or when friends show up hungry—it never fails to wow.

My family always gathers around the stove when this comes out of the oven. We fight over the crispy edges on the potatoes and drizzle that herby olive topping on everything. It is a staple in our house when the craving for comfort meets the need for something special.

Ingredients

• Baby potatoes: split for creamy insides and crisp outsides look for firm smooth skins
• Extra virgin olive oil: brings richness and helps everything caramelize try a peppery one if possible
• Salt and black pepper: basic seasoning for balance use sea salt and freshly ground pepper
• Boneless chicken breasts or thighs: moist protein base thighs are extra juicy if you like
• Balsamic vinegar: adds a sweet tang and deep flavor select a syrupy aged one for best taste
• Dijon mustard: brightens the marinade and helps everything stick choose a smooth French type
• Fresh oregano: sharp earthiness and color snip from a plant if you can
• Smoked or regular paprika: gives warmth and color smoked adds extra depth
• Garlic cloves: chopped for bold punch always pick firm bulbs
• Shallot: subtle sweetness try to find small firm ones
• Chili flakes: for gentle heat use more or less to taste
• Lemon juice: makes everything pop use fresh squeezed for the best zing
• Mixed fresh herbs: dill basil thyme each add a special fragrance pick perky green leaves
• Sliced pepperoncini: tangy crunch for contrast buy whole and slice thin
• Green olives: torn for briny richness look for firm meaty ones
• Sesame seeds: give gentle nutty crunch toast them lightly for extra flavor
• Tzatziki sauce: creamy tangy base you can use store bought or homemade
• Feta cheese: crumbled for salty creamy topping use a block and crumble for best texture

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the Oven:

Set the oven to 425 F well before starting to allow it to preheat so the potatoes and chicken cook evenly

Roast the Potatoes:

Toss halved baby potatoes with two tablespoons olive oil right on a rimmed sheet pan scatter them out with plenty of space and sprinkle lightly with salt and black pepper bake for about ten minutes while prepping the chicken this jump starts the crisping process

Marinate the Chicken:

In a large bowl combine two tablespoons olive oil balsamic vinegar Dijon mustard fresh oregano paprika chopped garlic chopped shallot a pinch of salt black pepper and a shake of chili flakes mix well then add chicken pieces roll them so every side is coated let them absorb flavor while potatoes start roasting

Arrange and Bake:

Nestle the chicken pieces among the par-cooked potatoes after ten minutes return the pan to the oven continue roasting for twenty five to thirty minutes until chicken is cooked through and potatoes are golden and tender juices will sizzle and make everything caramelize

Make the Herby Olive Topping and Sauce:

In a small bowl blend the remaining third cup olive oil with lemon juice chopped dill basil or thyme sliced pepperoncini torn green olives and sesame seeds toss well so the flavors meld for the sauce mix tzatziki with crumbled feta until creamy and tangy

Serve:

Once chicken and potatoes are ready spoon the herby olive topping over everything serve straight from the pan with plenty of tzatziki feta sauce on the side get all the drippings

Pin

The herby olive topping has become my favorite finishing touch for almost anything I roast lately I remember my brother once arriving late to dinner and eating the leftovers cold straight from the fridge it is just that delicious

Storage Tips

Transfer any leftovers to airtight containers and refrigerate for up to three days The chicken stays juicy and the potatoes taste even better as the flavors meld I often reheat single servings in the oven so the potatoes crisp back up or sneak a few bites cold for a snack

Ingredient Substitutions

You can use bone in chicken thighs or drumsticks for richer flavor and juicier meat Just add five to ten minutes to the bake time If you are out of oregano swap in rosemary or marjoram If you cannot find pepperoncini try jarred banana peppers For a dairy free version skip the feta and tzatziki or use coconut yogurt as a creamy base

Serving Suggestions

This pan meal feeds six as a main course but it shines as a crowd feature with fresh bread for soaking up juices Sometimes I add a quick cucumber tomato salad on the side To make a picnic out of it pack the chicken and potatoes into wraps with extra tzatziki and greens

Pin

A Little History

Lemon balsamic and herb marinades are classic in Mediterranean kitchens where simple sheet pan meals celebrate seasonal vegetables and whatever protein is on hand The pepperoncini and olive accents borrow from both Greek and Italian tables This recipe is proof that a few high quality ingredients can make a humble dinner taste restaurant worthy

Frequently Asked Questions About the Recipe

→ Can I use chicken thighs instead of breasts?

Yes, both boneless skinless chicken thighs or breasts work well. Thighs add extra juiciness and rich flavor.

→ What substitutes work for feta cheese in the sauce?

Try goat cheese or ricotta for a milder flavor, or skip cheese for a dairy-free option.

→ How do I ensure the potatoes are cooked through?

Halve the baby potatoes and spread them evenly on the pan to roast until fork-tender.

→ Can the dish be prepared ahead?

Yes, prep the marinade and feta sauce in advance. Bake when ready to serve for best results.

→ Is it possible to add more vegetables?

Absolutely! Try carrots, zucchini, or bell peppers, adjusting roasting time as needed.